The Revolutionary Art Theory of Hal Foster: The Return of the Real

Introduction: Unpacking the Avant-Garde Hal Foster’s The Return of the Real: The Avant-Garde at the End of the Century (1996) presents a profound exploration of avant-garde art and its legacy. The book examines how postwar artistic practices engage with historical avant-garde movements while addressing contemporary social, political, and cultural realities. Foster’s critical framework draws heavily on psychoanalytic theory, particularly Jacques Lacan, and poststructuralist thought, positioning his analysis at the intersection of art, ideology, and representation.

Foster begins by challenging the widespread notion that the neo-avant-garde merely replicates the innovations of the historical avant-garde. Instead, he argues for a cyclical relationship where past and present practices engage in dialogue, reinterpreting and transforming earlier strategies to confront the specific challenges of their time. This approach underscores Foster’s belief that avant-garde art cannot be understood in isolation but must be contextualized within broader cultural and historical forces.

Source: arqsc

Art, Representation, and the Body

Central to Foster’s thesis is the shift in contemporary art toward materiality and corporeality, encapsulated in the concept of “the return of the real.” He identifies a renewed focus on the visceral aspects of human experience in the works of artists like Cindy Sherman and Robert Gober, who employ corporeal imagery to address themes of identity, sexuality, and mortality. Drawing on Lacanian psychoanalysis, Foster interprets this as a reengagement with the traumatic "real"—that which resists representation but exerts a profound influence on human perception and creativity.

In earlier chapters, such as “The Passion of the Sign,” Foster examines the semiotic turn in postmodern art. Artists such as Barbara Kruger and Sherrie Levine deconstructed cultural and ideological constructs by manipulating symbols and signs. However, Foster critiques the detachment inherent in such practices, suggesting that the neo-avant-garde’s return to the physical body and raw materiality offers a counterpoint to the abstract, disembodied tendencies of postmodernism.

Minimalism, as discussed in “The Crux of Minimalism,” also plays a pivotal role in Foster’s narrative. He explores how artists like Donald Judd and Robert Morris emphasized the material and spatial presence of art, moving beyond representation to foreground the direct, phenomenological experience of the viewer. This redefinition of the relationship between art and its audience marked a significant departure from traditional artistic practices.

The Legacy and Challenges of the Avant-Garde

Foster’s critical engagement with the avant-garde extends to its political and social implications, particularly in “The Artist as Ethnographer.” He critiques the trend of artists adopting ethnographic methods to engage with marginalized communities, warning of the risks of perpetuating colonial power structures despite their subversive intentions. Foster calls for a more reflexive approach that acknowledges the complexities of representation and the artist's positionality within those systems.

The book concludes with a reflective critique of postmodernism’s fragmentation and relativism. While Foster acknowledges postmodernism’s challenges to authority and hierarchy, he advocates for a renewed search for meaning that navigates the tension between skepticism and engagement. In this, The Return of the Real becomes not just a historical analysis but a call for critical practice in the evolving landscape of contemporary art.

Conclusion

Hal Foster’s The Return of the Real is a masterful interrogation of the relationships between art, history, and society. Through his rigorous analysis of avant-garde practices, Foster illuminates the cyclical nature of artistic innovation and its enduring relevance in addressing the complexities of the modern world. By positioning art as a site of resistance, reflection, and renewal, Foster’s work remains a cornerstone of contemporary art criticism, offering invaluable insights for scholars, artists, and theorists alike.